Should I Sell Investments to Pay Off My Mortgage?

Quick Answer: Should You Sell Investments to Pay Off Your Mortgage?

There is no universal answer. Paying off a mortgage creates a guaranteed return by eliminating future interest costs, while staying invested provides the opportunity for higher returns but includes market risk. The decision depends on your mortgage rate, investment horizon, taxes, and need for accessible cash.

The Guaranteed Return of Paying Off a Mortgage

When you pay down your mortgage, you effectively earn a return equal to your mortgage interest rate. For example, paying off a 6% mortgage is similar to receiving a guaranteed 6% return because you avoid future interest charges.

Mortgage Rate vs Expected Investment Returns

Many investors compare mortgage interest rates with expected stock market returns. While investments may generate higher average returns over long periods, those returns are not guaranteed and markets can decline when you need the money.

Consider Taxes Before Selling Investments

Selling a brokerage account may create capital gains taxes depending on your cost basis and investment type. The after-tax return of your investments should be compared with the guaranteed savings from paying down your mortgage.

Liquidity: The Cost of Becoming Mortgage-Free

A paid-off home provides security, but home equity is less liquid than cash or investments. Once investments are converted into home equity, accessing that money may require selling the property or borrowing against it.

When Paying Off the Mortgage Makes Sense

Paying off the mortgage may make sense when interest rates are high, you value financial security, you have sufficient emergency savings, and you prefer a guaranteed return over investment uncertainty.

When Keeping Investments May Be Better

Keeping investments may make sense when you have a long investment timeline, can tolerate market volatility, need liquidity, or expect investment returns to exceed your mortgage cost after taxes.

A Balanced Approach: Partial Mortgage Payoff

You do not always need to choose between investing and paying off the mortgage completely. Some homeowners make a partial principal payment while keeping investments and cash reserves.

Example: Paying Off a $800,000 Mortgage at 6%

A homeowner with an $800,000 mortgage at 6% could compare the guaranteed interest savings from eliminating the debt with the potential after-tax growth of keeping investments invested. The best choice depends on personal circumstances rather than one universal rule.

Use a Mortgage Payoff Calculator

A mortgage payoff calculator can help estimate interest savings from additional payments and compare different payoff strategies.

Key Takeaway

Selling investments to pay off a mortgage is a major financial decision. A high mortgage rate makes debt payoff more attractive, but taxes, liquidity, and investment goals should all be considered before making a large move.

Frequently Asked Questions

Explore More Loan Topics